surrounded by clouds

On The Travel Diaries: Kim

IMG_0171Whilst I’m out of the country on a trip to a mysterious undisclosed location, the daily blogging will be achieved through a series of travel-related posts, thanks to the kindness of my friends and family, and the wonders of post-scheduling technology.

This installment of The Travel Diaries is brought to you by Kim Reid. Kim is married to Stephen and they have two sons, Silas and Oisín. Kim has travelled a lot, including living (and marrying, and having a baby) in South Africa, but she now lives back in Australia, and blogs here.

The Long Way Down

In ‘The Long Way Round’ best friends Ewan McGregor and Charley Boorman, ride heavy as sin BMW motorbikes from London to New York, through Europe, China, Mongolia, Russia, Canada and the US. It was such a success they decided to do it again, still on the heavy bikes, this time from Scotland to Cape Town, through Europe and Africa. This expedition is named, you got it, ‘The Long Way Down’. I watched them in solidarity with my motorbike-riding husand, and although skeptical, I actually find it pretty entertaining.

kimpost1

Both series boast amazing scenery, hardcore camping (at times), skin scraping crashes and of course victory of man over obstacle. There are moments of real hilarity, some homo-erotic skinny dipping in freezing rivers and lots of interesting cross-cultural observations.

But I think there are some serious problems with the ‘Long Way’ series too. My main beef is with the pernicious imperialistic overtones of the trips. The ‘adventure journey in a foreign land with cutesie natives’ motif is laid on pretty thick. In fact it would be laughable, if it wasn’t damaging, how cliched Ewan and Charley’s experiences and interactions with the local people and landscape are.

This particularly grates me in ‘The Long Way Down’. Charley And Ewan (and their sizeable support team) travel south through Africa exploring, purveying, discovering and laughing all the way down. They see cool animals and spectacular desert sunsets. Their hearts are wrenched by poverty and history. They test the clockwise/anticlockwise spinning of water at the Equator. They even have dinner with President Paul Kagame, the spoiler or saviour of Rwanda, depending on who you ask.

The whole trip is marked by imperialistic cliches. They visit locals in their stick and mud huts and say “I love the way they live, it’s so simple! I wish my life was more like this”, all the while knowing full well they’re going home to a multi-story townhouse with a stainless steel kitchen. Almost every black man they meet is quizzed about how many wives he has. They shake their skinny booty with voluptuous black women. They stay at campgrounds lit by Survivor-style torches and eat rustic, but lavish, meals prepared by chef-hat-wearing locals. They cuddle a lot of smiling black children. They give the impression that merely by visiting a village and chatting awkwardly with the locals they are making a difference, just by virtue of being from the West. They bemoan the inefficiency and poverty of border crossings. And I think worst of all, the trip is rounded off with this – “I truly found myself in Africa” – as they board the plane to go back to their normal lives.

kimpost2

This kind of trip now forms a large niche market of the travel industry. Along with a drunken tour of German cities and Thai beaches any aspiring young traveller should hope for a ‘mercy mission’ style adventure to see the simple and bizarre lives of people different to themselves. Indeed Charley and Ewan’s Round and Down trips are sponsored by exactly this kind of travel company.

This style of travel is reminiscent of the imperialistic journeys of the British or American or Spanish or French colonisers of previous centuries – but it’s dressed up differently. Now instead of racing to carve out lines on a map or gain control of resources and industries, it’s about mapping the individual’s soul, paying a pittance for handcarved souvenirs and recording it all on instagram.

These trips can patronise and commodify the lives and lifestyles of people living in these usually very poor countries. Instead of this kind of treatment, people living in poor communities in these countries need real investment in local business, aid assistance that gets down to the little people, support for fledgling governments or persecuted minorities, real solutions for corruption – all through culturally appropriate means. This is what will help. Not cuddles with a white man in front of an SLR.

In summary: the long way down.

Advertisements
This entry was published on July 4, 2013 at 1:37 pm. It’s filed under Travel and tagged . Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post.

One thought on “On The Travel Diaries: Kim

  1. Oh Kim, you know how to challenge us 🙂
    I agree with so much of this, that too often Westerners travel with all the wrong ideas, all the wrong approaches, with much too much faith in their own superiority.
    I think there’s another side to it though – the difficulty of telling someone else’s story. Because I don’t think travel in and of itself is a bad thing, and I don’t even think travel to a poor country is a bad thing (of course the how is important). But even when you go with the right approach, use the right companies, invest in the right places – telling the stories of what you saw and who you met is a cultural and ethical minefield.
    Have you read any of D.L.Mayfield’s “War Photographer” series? She and her guest bloggers deal with this issue so well I think. You might appreciate their perspective.
    http://dlmayfield.wordpress.com/war-photographer-series/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: